The Pipers Arrive: Establishing the American Education System in Surigao

03 December 2025 Feature | Surigao Historical Society | Local History
The Pipers Arrive: Establishing the American Education System in Surigao

The Cartilla's End: Confronting a Legacy of "Blessed Ignorance"

For centuries, Spanish rule in Surigao—and indeed across the archipelago—had prioritized spiritual conversion over widespread secular learning, resulting in a lamentable educational environment. Under the Spanish system, education came to a dead-stop after the basic instruction provided by the Cartilla. This deliberate colonial policy sought to keep the Indios in a state of "blessed ignorance" so that they would be easier to handle. While Jesuit efforts, particularly those of Fr. Luengo, did lay the foundation for elementary education, resulting in schools in all eleven parishes and 16 out-stations by the end of Spanish rule, there was no secondary school or college in the entire province when the Spaniards departed.

This intellectual void was the landscape inherited by the first American administrators.

Harbingers of the American Dream

The transition from Spanish to American sovereignty brought an immediate and dramatic shift in colonial strategy. Following in the wake of the soldiers, the first Americans to arrive in Surigao in 1901-1902 were teachers, nurses, and prospectors, almost immediately seeking to establish a public education system.

These pioneer American educators became popularly, though indiscriminately, known as the "Thomasites," a moniker derived from the troop-ship USS Thomas which transported the first large group of teachers to the Philippines in August 1901. The subsequent American teachers who came aboard various transport vessels were all generally referred to by this apostolic name.

The Thomasites were driven by a missionary zeal to spread the American way of life and culture, acting as "new evangelists" in the predominantly Catholic province. Upon arrival, they found an educational vacuum. Makeshift schoolhouses were in the hands of "decrepit, old men and women who did not know any other language except the local dialect" and had no concept of modern education.

The American response was drastic and immediate. They quickly replaced these elderly locals with young people. In almost every case, they were "compelled to take young men and women of absolutely no previous preparation who in many cases could scarcely read and write in their own dialect". The arduous task then began: turning these raw recruits into instructors capable of teaching in a "strange and foreign language" (English).

The Pipers’ Call and the People's Choice

Despite the Thomasites' dedication, their early efforts faced significant hurdles. Attendance was initially poor due to cholera and smallpox epidemics, the lack of carabaos (forcing children to work in the fields), and "Church opposition" in towns where Catholic priests had already opened their own schools. Furthermore, the ongoing nationalist resistance meant American troops occupied many school buildings, disrupting instruction.

However, the American educational push, backed by a philosophy that recognized the Filipinos' "tremendous potentials" and viewed American teachers primarily as "supervisors," quickly gained momentum. This new education offered the Surigaonons "deliverance from the bondage of poverty" and the prospect of social and economic upliftment. Having suffered under centuries of Spanish oppression and witnessing the failure of the Filipino struggle for independence, the populace quickly embraced the change. The "innocent folks simply followed the Pied Pipers of the American dream".

5 Questions to Spark Your Curiosity

1. From Cartilla to Curriculum: The Spanish colonial government ensured "blessed ignorance" by limiting education to the basic Cartilla. How did this history of educational suppression impact the capacity and willingness of the first generation of Surigaonons to embrace the comprehensive American public school curriculum, which aimed for total Americanization?

2. The Double-Edged Sword of the Thomasite Mission: The American teachers were described as "new evangelists" spreading American culture. Was the immediate and widespread acceptance of the American system in Surigao a genuine reflection of cultural preference, or a pragmatic choice for "deliverance from the bondage of poverty" offered by the new economic opportunities attached to this education?

3. The American and Spanish Educational Legacies: Despite the American success, the Spanish Jesuits were praised for laying the foundational structures of elementary education in the parishes before 1898. How do the modern educational institutions in Surigao reconcile these two distinct colonial educational foundations in defining their institutional heritage?

4. Language and Identity: The first local teachers were forced to adopt a "strange and foreign language" (English). How did the forced adoption of English as the medium of instruction during the American period accelerate the erosion of local dialects and traditional forms of writing, such as Baybayin (or Suwat Bisaya), in favor of a new, nationalized Filipino identity?

5. The Piedmont of Progress: The Americans quickly established the Provincial High School, unlike the Spanish. How did the American commitment to creating a centralized, modern education center in Surigao City permanently shape the geographic distribution of power, opportunity, and status within the province, separating those who lived bajo de las campanas (under the church bells) from those in the interior?

Explore Further, Engage Deeper

This story is just one of many hidden within the pages of Surigao Across the Years. To explore more: Interact with the book through Artificial Intelligence (AI):
Visit the customized GPT by Open AI HERE and the Book Section of the Surigao Historical Society HERE

Click here to know the Editorial Team, Copyright and Authorized Digital Use Statement